"I may say that this is the greatest factor -- the way in which the expedition is equipped -- the way in which every difficulty is foreseen, and precautions taken for meeting or avoiding it. Victory awaits him who everything in order -- luck, people call it. Defeat is certain for him who has neglected to take the necessary precautions in time; this is called bad luck."
--from The South Pole by Roald Amundsen

Just as Amundsen carefully equipped his expedition before embarking on his journey, as we embark on our journey of analyzing these two structures our goal is to develop a toolkit containing the essential ingredients for survival in an isolated community. Our aim is to extract the information we acquire, so the methods of survival can be applied to other structures in similar conditions.

Toolkit

Toolkit

1/17/2010

Heat

Machinery stops working at a temperature of approximately -40 degrees Celsius. Aircraft stops working at a temperature of approximately -45 degrees Celsius. Symptoms of hypothermia begin to appear when a human's core body temperature drops one or two degrees Celsius. With the South Pole reaching temperatures downwards of -60 degrees Celsius during the winter, it comes as no surprise that any structure that is to survive within the Antarctic climate must be designed to accommodate such extreme cold.

The wall sections seen below show how each structure incorporates insulation in order to retain whatever heat exists inside. Although the Fram’s section is much wider, this has more to do with the fact that the hull of the ship had to be extremely strong, and therefore had to have many layers of wood. Amundsen actually worked to maximize the efficiency of the insulation while reducing the amount of space it took up. The layers of wood – especially the greenheart – also were used to make sure that ice and snow did not seep inwards and destroy the ship.

Fram Wall Section


ASSPS Wall Section

The diagram below illustrates how the insulation works in order to hold the heat inside across the whole structure. This is especially important for the Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station. Typically, a building resting on ice will emit heat from all areas, thus forming a thermal bulb underneath the building. As explained later, this leads to differential settlement. The ASSPS combats this by heavily insulating the floor and the substructure, and only having columns break through to the substructure. This means that essentially no heat is released through the floor. Once again, this will be explained in depth elsewhere.





We now understand how heat is retained, but the next concern is how it is generated. Due to technological limitations, the Fram had to use petroleum to heat the ship, and the crew made use of extremely warm outerwear when above or below deck. In the laboratory, warm air is brought in from the galley.

Roald Amundsen and his Nifty Winter Gear


The Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station took this idea of piping in warm air to a whole new level. They used heat exchangers to capture waste heat from different areas, and then moved the heat to where it was needed. This mainly takes place in the power plant, as shown below, where the diesel engines are situated.



Diesel Engine and its Waste Heat


Distribution of Waste Heat from the Power Plant


Waste heat is also captured from other areas of the building, such as the kitchen, the green room, and various electronic rooms.



Other Areas Where Waste Heat is Captured

No comments:

Post a Comment